Intel Xeon 3.6 (Nocona) vs. AMD Opteron 250 - Database Test
by Jason Clark & Ross Whitehead on September 13, 2004 12:05 AM EST- Posted in
- IT Computing
Final Words
Intel managed to raise the bar in our small to medium tests, and matched the Opteron 250's performance. Thanks to a 400MHz clock increase and a 266 MHz FSB increase, Intel is competitive in a small-medium load pattern like our test simulates. Although the results in the enterprise workload were interesting, they really aren't all that surprising. As we said in the "AMD Opteron vs. Intel Xeon: Database Performance Shootout" article, the Xeon's shared FSB implementation is holding back performance. The longer pipeline of the Prescott core was also a factor, as the Nocona 3.6 barely managed a 1% lead in performance over the Prestonia 3.2 GHz part.AMD shows strength in architecture again; their point-to-point HyperTransport and the on die memory controller are the pillars of AMD's server architecture. The question is, does it translate into market share? Time will tell on this one. Hopefully, the results that we are illustrating here will make IT directors and those responsible for implementation educate themselves on the processor architectures available to them.
44 Comments
View All Comments
knitecrow - Monday, September 13, 2004 - link
Something caught my eye:"The difference in performance between the Opteron 250 and the Nocona 3.6 is approximately 2%, which is also our tolerance for deviation between test runs."
I know its an unfair charge to level against this site, as everyone does it, but why aren't there any error bars?
In my freshman physics class they really made the point that graphs with out error bars are useless.... and the work was rubbish.
Just by looking at the graph I can't tell the variance or the margin of error. Wouldn't it be helpful if we had the information?
Anyway, just a thought.
saechaka - Monday, September 13, 2004 - link
the message is clear the beat must go onMAME - Monday, September 13, 2004 - link
AMD > Intel once againShadowmage - Monday, September 13, 2004 - link
The Opteron applies extreme beats yet again! :D